On Sunday, October
28, 2012, a Canadian delegation to the Organization for Security and
Co-operation in Europe Parliamentary Assembly (OSCE PA), led by Mr. James
Bezan, M.P., and composed of the Honourable Senator Michel Rivard, the
Honourable Senator Larry Campbell, Mr. Ed Komarnicki, M.P., Mr. Wladyslaw
Lizon, M.P., Mr. Corneliu Chisu, M.P., Mr. Ted Opitz, M.P., Ms. Peggy Nash,
M.P., Ms. Linda Duncan, M.P., Ms. Ève Péclet, M.P., the Honourable Lawrence
MacAulay, M.P. and the Honourable Judy Sgro, M.P., participated in an election
observation mission that monitored the parliamentary elections held in Ukraine.
The delegation was accompanied by Andrew Lauzon, Association Secretary.
A.The Election Observation Mission in Ukraine
A key element of
the OSCE’s mandate is the promotion of democratic elections. To this end, the
Canadian delegation to OSCE PA has participated in numerous international
election observation missions. As a community of countries committed to
democracy, the OSCE has placed great emphasis on promoting democratic elections
as a key pillar of stability. All OSCE participating States have committed
themselves to invite international observers to their elections, in recognition
that election observation can play an important role in enhancing confidence in
the electoral process. Deploying election observers offers demonstrable support
to a democratic process and can assist OSCE participating States in their
objective to conduct genuine elections in line with OSCE commitments.
The OSCE election
observation mission in Ukraine was a common endeavour, involving the Office for
Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR), the OSCE PA, the
Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE), the European Parliament
(EP) and the NATO Parliamentary Assembly (NATO PA). The mission was deployed at
the invitation of the Government of Ukraine, pursuant to commitments made by
all OSCE participating states.
On election-day,
802 observers from 42 countries were deployed, including 623 long-term and
short-term observers deployed by the OSCE/ODIHR, as well as 94 parliamentarians
and staff from the OSCE PA, 41 from the PACE, 25 from the EP and 19 from the
NATO PA. Voting was observed in 2,521 polling stations across the country.
Counting was observed in 249 polling stations. The tabulation process was
observed in 126 District Election Commissions.
B.Activities of the Canadian Delegation
Canadian delegates
attended briefing sessions provided by the OSCE for parliamentarians on Friday,
October 26, and Saturday, October 27, 2012, in Kyiv, Ukraine. Over the course
of the two days, delegates were provided with an overview of the political
background to the elections. They were also briefed on the administration of
the elections, as well as the process for election-day reporting and
statistical analysis. The delegates heard presentations from domestic observer
organisations, non-governmental organizations and media representatives.
Furthermore, they met with representatives from the political parties and
blocs.
On Friday, October
26, the delegation attended a situational briefing provided by Troy Lulashnyk,
Ambassador of Canada to Ukraine. Also in attendance at the briefing were
Senator Raynell Andreychuk, Head of Mission for Mission Canada – Ukraine
Elections 2012, and Paul Grod, Head of Mission for the Ukrainian World Congress
Election Observation Mission.
Mr. Bezan and Mr.
Lizon were appointed as regional coordinators of OSCE PA teams being deployed
on election day. Mr. Bezan was the regional coordinator for the Chernivtsi
region and Mr. Lizon was the regional coordinator for the Ivano-Frankivsk
region. Furthermore, Mr. Bezan was appointed as a member of the Advisory Group
to Ms. Walburga Habsburg Douglas, the Special
Co-ordinator who led the OSCE short-term election observation mission and the
Head of the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly delegation. He attended a meeting of
the Advisory Group on Friday, October 26.
On Sunday, October
28, the delegates were deployed across Ukraine to observe the elections. Mr.
Bezan and Ms. Péclet were deployed to the Chernivtsi region. Mr. Komarnicki and
Mr. Lizon were deployed to the Ivano-Frankivsk region. Mr. Chisu, Mr. Opitz and
Ms. Duncan were deployed to the Lviv region. Senator Rivard was deployed to the
Odessa region. Senator Campbell, Ms. Nash, Mr. MacAulay and Ms. Sgro were
deployed to the Kyiv region.
On election-day,
the delegates observed several aspects of the election process, including:
·The opening of a polling station in the morning;
·the voting process in a number of polling stations
throughout election day;
·the closing of a polling station and the vote
count in that polling station;
·the transfer of election material to the
District Election Commission (DEC) and handover at the DEC;
·the processing of election materials and the tabulation
of results at the DEC, including on Monday, October 29, where necessary.
The delegates
reported regularly on their observations throughout the day by completing
observation report forms at each polling station visited and submitting them to
their assigned long-term observers.
On the morning of
Monday, October 29, delegates who had been deployed in the Kyiv region attended
the OSCE debriefing. Ms. Habsburg Douglas presented a summary of the
statistical information derived from the submitted observation report forms.
The parliamentarians present also discussed their observations on election-day
and made recommendations concerning the content of the “Statement of
Preliminary Findings and Conclusions”. In the evening, the Canadian delegation
hosted a debriefing with Ambassador Lulashnyk. It was also attended by Senator
Andreychuk, Ann Szyptur, Mission Canada – Ukraine Elections 2012 Long-Term
Observer Coordinator, and Taras Zalusky, Mission Canada – Ukraine Elections
2012 Chief of Staff.
C.Preliminary Findings and Conclusions
The OSCE PA was
disappointed to report that these elections appear to represent a reversal of
Ukraine’s democratic progress. On the positive side, election-day was calm and
peaceful overall and voter turnout was healthy, at 58%. A competitive and
visible campaign was fought by distinct parties representing a range of
political perspectives and the people of Ukraine were engaged in the election
process. Furthermore, candidate registration was inclusive, with two
notable exceptions, representing a wide variety of political views. Two
prominent opposition political figures, Ms. Yulia Tymoshenko and Mr. Yuriy
Lutsenko, remained imprisoned during the election period, following trials that
were highly criticized as unfair by the OSCE PA. Neither Ms. Tymoshenko nor Mr.
Lutsenko was permitted to register as a candidate for the election.
The influence of
economically powerful groups negatively affected the overall fairness of the
campaign. For example, political parties had unequal access to private media
coverage and campaign financing lacked transparency. Media coverage on
state-run television was also notably biased in favour of the ruling party.
Moreover,
tabulation was problematic, as it lacked transparency. The tabulation
process was assessed negatively by fully one-third of international observers.
Overall, the transparency of the tabulation of results was limited and a number
of international observers reported being restricted in their observation of
the process.
On the whole, the
engagement of Ukrainians in the election showed that support for democracy in
the country is strong. Unfortunately, the detention of prominent opposition
political figures, the absence of a level playing field for opposition
candidates during the campaign period, and a lack of transparency in the
tabulation of election results cast a shadow over the process.
The full
preliminary report, prepared jointly by the OSCE PA, ODIHR, PACE, EP and NATO
PA missions, is available in English at the following site: http://www.osce.org/odihr/96675.
Respectfully submitted,
Mr. Dean Allison, M.P.
Director Canadian Delegation to the Organization for Security
and Co-operation in Europe Parliamentary Assembly
(OSCE PA)