At the invitation of the China-Canada Legislative
Association (China), a Canadian parliamentary delegation, led by the Co-Chairs
of the Canada-China Legislative Association (Canada), the Hon. Joseph A. Day,
Senator and Mr. Daryl Kramp, Member of Parliament, visited the People’s
Republic of China from September 18 to 27, 2009. The delegation participated
in the Twelfth Bilateral Consultation between the two respective associations.
The Eleventh Bilateral Consultation held in Canada in June 2009, resulted in
the agreement that both sides work to strengthen the exchange
mechanism, deepen friendship and further develop cooperation between the two
countries, and this particularly in light of the upcoming celebration marking
the 40th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations
between Canada and China.
In essence, the objectives of the visit
were as follows:
·to continue the renewal and reinvigoration of
the CCLA relationship following the 11th Bilateral meeting of June
2009;
·to apprise the Chinese of the political
situation in Canada;
·to learn more about Chinese-Canadian business,
cultural and political links, and to promote enhanced cooperation at all these
levels;
·to discuss the parameters of the upcoming
celebrations marking the 40th anniversary of the establishment of
diplomatic relations between Canada and China; and
·to promote friendship and establish regular
opportunities for dialogue with Chinese counterparts.
The delegation consisted of the
following Parliamentarians: Hon. Joseph A. Day, Senator and Co-Chair of the
CCLA, Mr. Daryl Kramp, M.P., Co-Chair of the CCLA, Hon. Terrance Stratton,
Senator, Hon. Grant Mitchell, Senator, Mr. Bob Dechert, M.P., Mr. Larry Miller,
M.P., Ms. Joyce Murray, M.P., and Mr. Mario Silva, M.P. The delegation, accompanied
by Ms. Elizabeth Kingston, Executive Secretary of the Canada-China Legislative
Association visited Beijing, X’ian, Guilin and Shenzhen.
Beijing:
At the outset of the visit, the
Canadian delegation attended a briefing offered by the Ambassador, David
Mulroney and other officials at the Canadian Embassy. The delegation
congratulated Ambassador Mulroney on his recent appointment as Canadian
Ambassador to China.
The briefing included the following
points: the importance of the long-standing and comprehensive relationship,
highlighted by the 40th anniversary of the establishment of
diplomatic relations in 2010; the mutual and beneficial trade and economic
relationship between both countries, the multilateral engagement of both
countries, as reflected in the G8 and G20 memberships, and the openness of both
countries for respectful and productive exchanges in the areas of human rights
and governance. The highlights of the Canada’s messaging to China were the
following: Canada is rich in natural resources, is an innovative society open
for business, offers tremendous educational opportunities, and is
multicultural, friendly and welcoming.
Meeting with Liu Jieyi –
Vice-Minister, International Department of the Communist Party of China (CPC)
Central Committee
It was stated that both Canada and
China have made great strides in developing a mature relationship, as recently
evidenced by the exchange of four ministers in the last six months. Moreover,
both sides agreed that the growing relationship has allowed for franker
discussions and increased cooperation. While critical statements made in a
public setting have created some measure of misunderstanding with the Chinese
people, and have led to the potential of undermining public support, the point
was made that it is important to discuss such misunderstandings in a frank and
constructive way, without making public declarations that may have the effect
of being misrepresented by the media. It was expressed by both sides that both
countries offer a wide range of mutual investment and collaboration, especially
in the areas of energy, climate change and clean technology, agriculture,
education as well as the environment and reforestation opportunities. The
Vice-Minister also highlighted the celebration of the upcoming year marking the
40th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations
between Canada and China.
Meeting
with Zhang Zhijun – Vice-Minister, Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Vice-Minister
Zhang noted the steady growth in the development of the relationship that has
led to the celebration of the 40th anniversary between the two
countries. China remains thankful to Canada for being amongst the first
countries to establish diplomatic relations with China. He stressed the
importance of parliamentary diplomacy by stating that bilateral relationships
cannot be further enhanced without the involvement of parliamentarians. While
Canada and China have an already robust economic relationship, he acknowledged
that much still remains to be accomplished especially in the areas of trade and
investment, including the development of the Pacific Gateway to mutually
enhance economic opportunities between the two countries. Moreover, given the
current world economic crisis and witnessed strength of the economies of both
China and Canada in weathering the crisis, it boasts an enhanced level of
collaborative opportunity for both countries. Both sides acknowledged the
strength of the banking sector in Canada, and noted that China could learn much
from Canada while it works to strengthen its own financial systems.
Other areas of collaboration were also
discussed, including the vast opportunity for educational and cultural
exchanges, and technology transfers especially in the area of green technology
and carbon capture initiatives. Mr. Zhang then went on to express that China,
with a population of over 1.3 billion people, needs for its very survival the
creation of economic means to feed its population, while pursuing
environmental opportunities that diminish China’s reliance on coal.
Meeting
with Canadian Business and Financial Sector Senior Representatives
The
delegation met with a number of senior Canadian business representatives, all
working in China in various areas of responsibility from banking to education
to product distribution and promotion. The principal elements of the discussion
were the following:
·With the fluctuation in the rate of the Canadian
dollar, it makes it difficult to set retail prices, particularly in such a
fiercely competitive marketplace;
·There is a general lack of awareness of import
regulations for China, and Canadian businesses would appreciate greater support
from the Canadian Government on educating them of these regulations, thereby
encouraging a greater foray into the marketplace; the support should be both
politically and financially driven;
·The Team Canada approach to expanding business
opportunities in China is dated and the Canadian Government should do more to
encourage sector based missions to China, possibly led by premiers or Ministers
following bilateral engagements;
·There should be more company to company bridge
building to mutually expand opportunities in both Canada and China;
·Those anticipating an entry into the Chinese
marketplace should ensure they have a value-added competitive edge;
·Education exchange and purchasing represents a
highly lucrative market with as much as $200 million generated each year for
Canada;
·China’s financial hold on the United States has
reached over 8 trillion dollars.
12th
Bilateral Working Meeting – Canada –China Legislative Association (CCLA):
Chairman
Zheng, Chair of the China-Canada Legislative Association, chaired the bilateral
discussion, which included the following subject areas: bilateral relations,
climate change, including carbon capture initiatives, the financial crisis,
tourism and power generation, including a follow-up to the AECL initiative.
Chairman Zheng provided the delegation
with a comprehensive outline of the economic situation stating that China’s GDP
has increased from 7.1% in the first quarter to 7.9% in the second quarter.
This increase has been achieved within the context of plummeting foreign trade.
The expected growth of 8% is therefore a realistic target for the year, and
particularly impressive considering the world wide economic crisis. China has
surpassed North America in the sale and production of automobiles, and along
with this success, environmental problems have increased, due to the larger
number of vehicles on China’s roads. He noted the subsidies provided to farmers
which in turn has led to an increase in the volume of sales for automobiles and
electrical appliances in particular. This increased spending power on the part
of Chinese citizens has led to an increase in its GDP. China’s shift has
occurred by lessening its dependence on foreign markets, where exports have
diminished by 22%, and promoting a greater spending capacity within. He also
stated that the low cost of manufacturing in China is due to the low cost of
labour and electricity, not through the provision of subsidies by the
government. He stressed the importance of the growing number of small and
medium enterprises in China and remarked upon the opportunities that present
themselves to both Canada and China in collaborating and forming strategic
alliances with SME’s between the two countries.
On the political front, Mr. Zheng
remarked that both Canada and China should be open in discussing irritants
between the two countries, most specifically as it concerns Tibet and Taiwan
while acknowledging similar values of the two countries as expressed in their
emphasis on good governance, human rights and accountability.
The Canadian delegation remarked that
Canada had been hit less seriously than other countries in the current economic
turmoil, largely due to its strong banking sector. Noting the suffering of the
automobile industry in particular, unemployment has been tagged at 10% in the
Toronto area, and 8.6% countrywide. There is some concern that the fragile
recovery may well experience a second dip, and that government intervention to
bolster the flagging economy should be withdrawn slowly so as to not exacerbate
the positive economic recovery signs.
Delegation members also acknowledged
the high level commitment Canada has expressed towards China, as reflected most
recently in the visits of five senior ministers to China, followed by the visit
of Prime Minister Stephen Harper. Also as the International Monetary Fund
(IMF) has rated Canada’s banking system as among the soundest in the world, it
bodes well for the increased collaboration of Canada and China in the financial
sector, as witnessed by the incorporation of the Bank of Montreal in China and
the subsequent opening of its offices in Beijing.
On the issue of AECL, Canadian
delegation members noted the great success of the sale of Candu reactors to
China where construction was completed on time and well under budget. Both
sides acknowledged the research being undertaken in the use of thorium as a
replacement for uranium, and expressed the exciting prospect that thorium may
well play an important role in the nuclear development of China as it moves to
diminish its dependence on coal-fired plants. Both sides agreed to investigate
further the progress made not only in the research to date, but also in the
ensuing commercialization phase.
The reliance of coal for China has led
in turn to the issue of carbon capture and storage initiatives, which in turn
can be used for enhanced oil recovery. It was suggested that Canada could be
very helpful in applying its technology in this respect in a wide-spread
industrialized manner.
The issue of bolstering the economic
opportunities for small and medium enterprises in Canada and China, especially
those concentrating on green technology initiatives was emphasized. In China,
SME’s account for 99.6% of the total number of enterprises, employ 75% of the
population, and play a huge role in China’s economic profile. This profile in
turn holds a huge opportunity for Canada and the idea was expressed to work
towards the signing of a Memorandum of Understanding between Canada and
China to pursue and solidify this most important initiative.
The area of agriculture and
particularly as it affects the import of beef and pork was discussed. China
acknowledged the efforts made by Canada to ensure the safety of its pork and
beef exports and both sides agreed to work towards an adjustment of policies to
ensure smooth economic trade mechanisms between the two countries.
Finally, it was stated that China is
carefully monitoring the effects of its stimulus package (4 trillion RMB) with
inspection troops being sent to regions throughout China to ensure that the
money has been spent in targeted areas.
Meeting
with Jiang Shusheng, Vice-Chairman of the Standing Committee of the National
People’s Congress
It was
agreed by both sides that the Canada-China Legislative Association has done
much to foster relations between the two countries. In fact the CCLA
represents for the National People’s Congress the first regular parliamentary
exchange mechanism as well as being the most stable. Moreover, China is most
appreciative of the fact that Canada was one of the first countries to
establish bilateral relations with Canada in 1970, and looks forward to the
upcoming 40th anniversary celebrations. Moreover, the relationship
between Canada and China can do much within the world context to work towards
global peace and security.
Areas of mutual concern and cooperation
include the world economic crisis, energy and environmental challenges. While
the size of both Canada and China are comparable and they are rich in both
natural and human resources, their populations are vastly different, with
China’s population expecting to reach over 1.5 billion people in the near
term. Education for both nations is a priority and educational and cultural
exchanges are very much of a burgeoning opportunity. It was noted that both
countries should continue to work together to improve the quality of education
and drive innovation at both the college and university level.
Visit
to Bank of Montreal Offices in Beijing:
The
following press release was issued by the Bank of Montreal following the visit
of the delegation to its Beijing offices on the occasion of its opening, on
Tuesday, September 22, 2009.
China's banking regulator has given
Bank of Montreal preliminary approval to incorporate in that country, a move
that will allow the bank to do everything from accept deposits in local
currency to sell investment products.BMO expects to receive final approval by
the middle of next year, making it the first Canadian bank – and one of roughly
30 foreign banks – to incorporate in China. Its desire to grow in the world's
second-largest economy is strong enough that it chose to begin the application
process with Chinese regulators last year, even as the financial crisis was
raging, said Albert Yu, who heads the bank's business in Asia. Some major U.S.
and European banks have reduced their stakes in Chinese banking since the
financial crisis erupted, including Royal Bank of Scotland and Bank of
America.“It's a very significant development for Bank of Montreal,” Mr. Yu said
in an interview from Beijing yesterday. “It does give us a long-term strategic
advantage. Incorporated foreign banks in China are considered partners in
building out a universal banking system.”Incorporation will allow BMO to take
yuan deposits, which will be an important source of funding, he said.
Incorporated banks can also participate in areas such as the fixed-income underwriting,
trading and sales business, and to apply to start up private equity and asset
management businesses. Chief executive officer Bill Downe has called China an
“emerging growth area for us.” While the bank has been active in the country
for decades, the business has for most of that time been what he characterizes
as “an option on the future,” he said last week at an investment conference BMO
has several businesses, from trade finance to foreign exchange to investment
banking, in the country. It's only in the past five years that they have been
profitable, Mr. Downe said. Now the bank plans to meld them under one common
umbrella, and Mr. Downe expects them to double or triple in size in coming
years. “When we've been talking in the past about China being less than 1 per
cent of business for the bank, you can start to put multiples on that 1 per
cent, going out over the next three to five years,” he said. It took much
relationship building and hard work to receive preliminary approval to
incorporate, Mr. Yu said. “Bill Downe himself is a frequent visitor to senior
Chinese leadership,” he said. Finance Minister Jim Flaherty accompanied a
delegation of representatives from Canada's financial sector to China this
summer. “Mr. Flaherty was nice enough to join us in some meetings that we
needed him to be present for,” Mr. Yu said, declining to expand on the
minister's role.“ We consider China to be critically important to complement
our strategy in Canada and the United States,” Mr. Yu added. BMO has three branches
in mainland China and one in Hong Kong.
Visit
to X’ian, Shaanxi Province:
X’ian,
with over 3,100 years of history, is the capital of Shaanxi Province and
located in the central northwest region of China. While being one of the
oldest cities in Chinese history, and one of the four Ancient Capital cities,
it is the eastern end of the Silk Road and the site of the Terra Cotta Army,
produced during the Qin Dynasty (221 – 206 BCE). Not only considered of
profound historic significance, X’ian is also an important industrial,
technological and education centre as well as being one of China’s most
important tourist destinations. It also is rich in natural resources, most
notably in coal, oil and natural gas and produces 29% of the world’s supply of
apple juice.
Not only did the delegation have the
opportunity of visiting the excavation site of the terra cotta warriors, it
also had the opportunity to witness the profound economic growth characterizing
this region by visiting two of the factories under the umbrella of the X’ian
Aircraft Industrial Corporation. The first factory produced component parts for
aircraft, being a principal supplier to both Airbus and Boeing. The Silver Line
Bus Company, having undertaken a joint venture with Volvo, produced buses at a
highly competitive cost. The clear message from these visits: if your business
case cannot survive being copied within a 90 day period, don’t undertake any
business venture in China.
Visit
to Guilin, Guangxi Province:
Guilin,
located in Guangxi province in the southern part of China and bordering Vietnam
to the southwest, has a population of around 49 million people. To its east is
Guangdong province. A popular tourist destination in China, it is renowned both
for its beautiful scenery bordering the Li River, with its majestic
beehive-like mountain peaks covered in lush greenery and since 1949, as one of
China’s five minority autonomous regions. There are in total 12 nationalities
and 25 smaller ethnic groups in the province. It is also rich in mineral
resources, especially metal ore.
While in Guilin, the delegation
received a briefing from the Consul General, François Rivest, who is
responsible for both Guangdong and Guangxi Provinces, as included in the
present visit. The briefing covered a broad range of issues, including the
opportunities for Canadian businesses in the economic powerhouse that is
Guangdong province. In particular the issue of the success of Australia in
breaking into the Chinese marketplace was discussed and particularly in Guangdong
Province, with the view that Canada should follow a similar strategy, namely:
1)A greater emphasis on the opportunities available for Canadian
based small and medium enterprises in China, and most particularly in
Guangdong, by increasing awareness and support within Canada for companies
wishing to break into the Chinese marketplace, especially affecting
intellectual property concerns;
2)A greater number of direct flights to Guangdong province to increase
the free flow of goods and services;
3)A greater emphasis on building relationships between Canada and
China at the political, provincial and corporate levels.
While in Guilin, the delegation visited
Guangxi Normal University and had the opportunity to speak with a number of its
students, all of whom expressed the wish to study in Canada. Founded in 1932,
the University is the second largest in Guangxi province, and has an enrolment
of over 30,000 students, representing over 32 countries, with 2 students and 4
professors from Canada. The University also houses an important landmark in
the history of China, that of a tribute to Sun Yat-sen, a Chinese revolutionary
and political leader, known in particular for his development of a political
philosophy known as the Three Principles founded on the tenants ofnationalism,
democracy and the people’s livelihood. A pioneer of Nationalist China, he is
often referred to as the Father of the Nation.
The delegation also had a meeting with
the Chairman of the Guilin Municipal Peoples’ Congress. Guilin is one of the 10
principal tourist destinations in China, and with the emphasis of both Canada
and China in promoting tourism, both sides agreed to promote their tourism
industries, while continuing to encourage the satisfactory resolution of the
issue of preferred destination status.
Visit
to Shenzhen, Guangdong Province:
Located
in the southern part of Guangdong Province and on the eastern side of the Pearl
River Delta, Shenzhen has experienced a most remarkable transformation as a
city and is firmly indicative of the China success story. A small fishing
village on the outskirts of Hong Kong only 29 years ago, it has now become an
economic powerhouse, with a population of over 8 million people and a growth
rate of an average 26% over the past 29 years. In 1980, the first Special
Economic Zone of China was built in Shenzhen. While the global economic crisis
has slowed somewhat the growth of Shenzhen, it has still managed a growth rate
of 12.1% in 2009. In recent years, a large part of its growth has been
attributed to the high tech sector.
While in Shenzhen, the delegation
visited the Topray Solar Company Ltd. Over the course
of more than 10 years in the solar industry, the company has developed solar
cells and modules using both thin film and crystalline technology. It also
manufactures solar consumer products including multifunctional solar battery
chargers, portable power supply systems, fountain pumps, solar lanterns, solar
radios and fan caps. Its clients include buyers from North America, Europe,
Africa and Australia. The company prides itself on its high ethical standards
and production means with little impact on the environment, and has been
recognized by the United nations as the recipient of the Bluesky Award. The
company would like to search for opportunities to invest in the Canadian
marketplace.
The delegation also visited the
Shenzhen Concord College of Sino-Canada. The college is a joint
Canadian-Chinese boarding school located in the Nanshan District of Shenzhen,
China. Another of its campuses is located in Beijing.
The agreement to the establishment of
SCCSC was signed on February 13th, 2001 in the presence of former Canadian
Prime Minister Jean Chrétien and Team Canada in Beijing. The signing instituted
the agreement between the Shenzhen Nanshan Education Bureau, the New Brunswick
Ministry of Education, and AKD International Incorporation to commence the
opening of the Shenzhen (Nanshan) Concord College of Sino-Canada on September
1st, 2001.
Doctor Francis Pang, Director of
UNESCO, is the Board Chairman of CCSC. Mr. Vernon Goodfellow, appointed by the
New Brunswick Ministry of Education, is the Canadian Principal of CCSC and
overseas the Canadian curriculum implemented at CCSC, thereby ensuring its
students a degree recognized both in Canada and in China.
The delegation also visited the Huawei
Company Headquarters. Shenzhen-based Huawei Technologies shot past
Alcatel-Lucent and Nokia Siemens in 2009 to become the world's No. 2
telecom-equipment provider, powered by quality and product upgrades on top of
its long-standing low prices. In the past year, it has won a slew of lucrative,
prestigious contracts -- Huawei recently beat out rivals Ericsson and Nokia
Siemens for a deal to build Norway's pioneering 4G cell-phone network, one of
the world's first -- and showed continued strength in the burgeoning Indian and
Chinese markets. The sum of these deals was good enough to double Huawei's
global market share to 20% and boost 2009 sales 17.5% to $21.5 billion.
The delegation also met with the
Chairman of the Standing Committee of the Shenzhen Municipal Peoples’ Congress,
Li Hongzhong and remarked on the fact that Shenzhen has been twinned with St.
John New Brunswick. The Chairman of the tremendous growth experienced by
Shenzhen over the past 29 years, principally due to its status as the first
special economic zone in China in 1980 and welcomed increased Canadian
investment in the region.
The 12th Bilateral visit
of the CCLA to China accomplished much to solidify the long-standing
relationship with their Chinese counterparts, and allowed the members of the
delegation the opportunity to witness the tremendous growth and history of the
country, while demonstrating unique opportunities for Canadian businesses in
the Chinese marketplace. Both associations are actively planning activities to
mark the 40th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic
relations, including holding two bilateral visits, and identifying
opportunities for both Canadian and Chinese small and medium enterprises to
mutually benefit from broadening their business opportunities within the
respective countries. Both sides remarked that as a result of these 40 years,
the relationship has matured to a point where mutual respect and trust are the
cornerstones by which a firm friendship, allowing for unique cultural,
educational, political and business opportunities to flourish.
Respectfully submitted,
Hon. Joseph A. Day, Senator
Co-Chair
Canada-China Legislative Association
Mr. Daryl Kramp, M.P.
Co-Chair
Canada-China Legislative Association