ParlAmericas held its 33rd Meeting of the Board of
Directors in the city of Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic. Participants
expressed gratitude to the host, Ms. Guadalupe Valdez, for the hospitality
shown to them in Santo Domingo. Mr. Randy Hoback, M.P. led a delegation
representing the Canadian Section of ParlAmericas, which also included the Hon.
Michael L. MacDonald, accompanied by Mrs. Guyanne L. Desforges, Association
Secretary to the Canadian Section. Mr. Hoback attended the meeting in his
capacity as President of ParlAmericas, and Senator MacDonald attended as the
Canadian representative on the Board of Directors.
The main objectives of the meeting were to hear
about progress on preparations for the 11th ParlAmericas Plenary Assembly to be
held in Chili, to receive various updates from Board members and Secretariat
staff, to approve proposals for the themes of the next Gathering of the Group
of Women Parliamentarians; to approve the work plan and budget for the coming
cycle and to discuss a funding strategy for the organization.
1. Meeting Opening (See
Appendix for a complete list of participants)
Mr. Randy Hoback, President and Chair of the
meeting, opened the session. He welcomed the meeting participants and thanked
Ms. Guadalupe Valdez, for her warm welcome, her support and for hosting this
ParlAmericas meeting. He also stated that he was looking forward to getting to
know the new Board members. He noted that the Association Secretary of the
Canadian section, Mrs. Guyanne Desforges, would be appointed Secretary in Ms.
Gina Hill’s absence.
Ms. Valdez welcomed the Board members on behalf of
the President of the Chamber of Deputies of the Dominican Republic, Mr. Abel
Martinez Durán, and the rest of the legislators. Mr. Hoback then invited the
participants to introduce themselves, and gave the regrets of those who could
not be in attendance. He took the opportunity to thank the outgoing Director
General (D.G.), Gina Hill who couldn’t attend the meeting. He then introduced
the new D.G., Ms. Alisha Todd who has worked in business development and
democracy programming. One of her points of focus as new D.G. will be to secure
funding.
a)Adoption of the Agenda
Mr. Hoback invited members to consider the draft
meeting agenda. The Board of Directors members agreed with the proposal, and
the agenda was adopted.
b)Approval of the Report of the 32nd Board of Directors Meeting
The meeting proceeded with the consideration of
the report of the 32nd ParlAmericas Board of Directors meeting, held in San
José, Costa Rica, on August 20 and 24, 2013.
2. President’s Report
Mr. Hoback referred to his written report as he
updated Board of Directors members on his activities. He highlighted in
particular his work with different ambassadors in Canada, and his participation
in the opening reception of the Canada-Colombia friendship group. In January,
Mr. Hoback was in Veracruz, Mexico, at the Atlantic Basin initiative. He
apologized for his absence in Costa Rica due to health reasons.
3. International Secretariat Report
Mr. Hoback then gave the floor to Anabella
Zavagno, the Program Manager, in the absence of the outgoing Director General
Gina Hill. She provided program and finance updates from the International
Secretariat, including the Director General’s Report, the work plan, and the
budget for approval.
Ms. Zavagno read the Director General’s Report
prepared by Gina Hill, which summarized her reflections on the recent past, and
the near future of ParlAmericas. It was noted that during her mandate the
organization underwent a complete rebranding, developed its first strategic
plan, and reformulated its regulations; now the priority must be placed on
securing funds for the organization.
4. Update on Recent Activities of Board of
Directors Members
Mr. Hoback invited other members of the Board to
speak to any activities they had undertaken in the name of ParlAmericas since
the last meeting. Ms. Simons reported that the workshop in Trinidad and Tobago
had been very successful, and on their return the members who participated were
very enthusiastic. There were immediate changes to the way they work with the
committee of expenditures of the state.
Mr. Buchanan said that the workshop in Trinidad
and Tobago on strengthening parliamentary budget oversight had been a great
opportunity, and there had been extensive participation from the region. He
acknowledged the great work Ms. Hill had done, and asserted that it was a very
insightful forum. In his opinion, participants went away with greater knowledge
on how to operate in Public Accounts Committees. There might be follow-up
workshops in certain countries to continue the dialogue, since the World Bank
representative expressed his interest in continuing with this initiative.
Ms. Simons stressed that ParlAmericas should do
more of this type of activities which are more direct and aim to tackle
practical problems. Mr. Hoback thought it was an excellent point, and must be
in line with possibilities of funding. He pointed out the success in regional
programs, and encouraged Board members to identify issues of interest. He also
noted there would be an upcoming Canadian mission to Peru, involving all
parties, which would be looking at the Pacific Alliance, the trade agreement,
and the extractive industry. He said he would like to do more bilateral trips,
but funding was limited.
5. Program Report,
Financial Presentation, Work Plan - April 2014 to March 2015
a)Program Report
Ms. Zavagno was again invited to speak, to go over
the major activities of the International Secretariat, corresponding to the six
streams of CIDA funding. She mentioned the organization and delivery of the
training for Caribbean countries on Parliamentary Budget Oversight; the
preparation and distribution of the 10thPlenary Assembly Report and
three editions of the newsletter ParlAmericas Express; the efforts to
secure a host country for the Gathering of the Group of Women Parliamentarians;
the work to increase ParlAmericas presence in social media and to review the website;
the preparation of the Corporation Bylaws and CIDA reports; and the
coordination of the transition of two senior roles at the International
Secretariat office. Then, Ms. Zavagno invited questions from the Board.
b)Financial Presentation
Ms. Zavagno turned to the financial presentation
to report on the budget forecast compared to actuals for the period from
October 1, 2012 to September 30, 2013. She walked the board through the
document, pointing out the three streams of income: membership dues, the CIDA
project, and other projects and revenues.
Ms. Zavagno drew the board’s attention to the
membership dues column that showed that ParlAmericas received more income than
was forecast, and said this was because it included both current and
outstanding dues from previous years. She also explained that under the other
projects and revenues column, the amount forecast was larger than the actuals,
as ParlAmericas had been expecting to carry out another joint project with the
World Trade Organization that unfortunately had fallen through. Nevertheless,
there was revenue due mainly to favourable exchange rates. Ms. Zavagno also
pointed out that as the CIDA project was coming to an end, a higher percentage
of the International Secretariat staff salaries would be absorbed by membership
dues revenue.
Mr. Urrutia asked for clarification regarding the
income from membership dues as he saw a great disparity between the forecast
and the actual income. He wanted to know where the estimated amount came from. Mr.
Hoback understood Mr. Urrutia’s concern, and explained that as more countries
were getting involved it was expected to have more membership dues collected.
He stressed that ParlAmericas would have to be aggressive to survive.
The Director General took the floor to say that
the forecasted amount included past dues that had not yet been paid, and might
appear in the bank account should these members regularize their situation. Ms.
Todd considered that a change in the way in which the figures are presented
would help to avoid confusion.
Mr. Blanco agreed with Ms. Valdez’s point to
include the in-kind investments / contributions of countries, especially when
they host events, in the budget. Mr. Urrutia raised his concern about members
that had never paid their membership dues. He considered that those parliaments
should not have the same right to a seat on the board as the parliaments that
have always paid. Mr. Urrutia was aware that this issue is a matter of
Regulations, but thought that the Board could pass a resolution to prevent a
member to run for a seat if said member has not paid at least the last
membership dues.
Mr. Hoback returned to the financial statement,
and there being no further questions, the Board of Directors approved, the budget
for the period October 1, 2012, to September 30, 2013.
c)Work Plan
Ms. Zavagno continued with the Work Plan for April
2014 to March 2015. She reminded the board that the CIDA Project will end in
December of this year, and the activities in the Work Plan reflected
ParlAmericas’ commitments under the project until then. Ms. Zavagno listed the
following planned activities: preparation and distribution of the report on the
workshop Strengthening Parliamentary Budget Oversight in the Caribbean -
Phase 2; conversations with the OAS regarding an ongoing project in Central
America, Mexico and the Dominican Republic; preparations for the Plenary
Assembly in Chile; publication of another edition of the newsletter ParlAmericas
Express; preparations for the Gathering of the Group of Women
Parliamentarians; revision and updates of the website and updates to the
database; coordination of board meetings; and implementation of the financing
strategy.
Mr. Hoback wanted the board to be aware of some
ideas that had come up during different conversations. One was including on the
board an associate member from the OAS; other idea was conducting the Plenary
Assembly in conjunction with the OAS General Assembly in future years. He also
talked about attending the OAS General Assembly in Paraguay, for which board members
would have to cover their costs since there was budget only for the President.
There being no further questions, the Board of
Directors approved, the proposed Work Plan for the year 2014-2015, as
presented.
6. Meetings of ParlAmericas Corporation Board
Senator MacDonald chaired three sessions/meetings
of the ParlAmericas Corporation (Board of Directors/Executive Members). He
reminded Members the need to conduct some ParlAmericas Corporation business in
order to comply with Canadian legal requirement for not-for-profit organizations,
where ParlAmericas is officially registered. It covered approval of minutes of
the annual meeting, financial statement and election of Board of Directors of
ParlAmericas Corporation.
7. Funding Beyond December 2014 – Part I –
Presentation by Consultant
Mr. Hoback explained that, as agreed at a previous
board meeting, and in keeping with the Funding Strategy, the International
Secretariat hired a consultant to work on seeking and securing funds for the
organization. He introduced Andrés López-Hoyos who had a solid experience
drafting reports and proposals and also had interesting international
experience including numerous observation missions with the OAS.
Mr. López-Hoyos informed the Board Members that he
had been hired to work on two key recommendations from the funding strategy of
the organization: 1) diversifying funding sources to secure long-term funding,
and 2) engaging member parliamentarians and expanding membership. He noted that
his presentation would be focused on the first objective: developing a
portfolio of potential funding sources and mechanisms to allow ParlAmericas to
operate with the necessary funds for the next 3-5 years.
Mr. López-Hoyos then stated that he reviewed
funding mechanisms in similar agencies; researched online organizations working
on projects and initiatives in sectors related to the work of ParlAmericas; and
interviewed key stakeholders.
He presented a list of organizations that could
potentially fund ParlAmericas, divided in four groups: governments, foundations,
international funding agencies, and private companies. Mr. López-Hoyos stressed
that the time-frame for approving funding inquiries could take many months,
which was extremely relevant in this case because ParlAmericas only had until
December 2014 to obtain funding.
The floor was open for discussion, and Mr. Blanco
mentioned the importance of reaching out to the Inter-American Development
Bank. Mr. López-Hoyos agreed, and said that they have twoprojects that
align with what ParlAmericas does. However, he was concerned about the time it
might take for a proposal to be approved. It was noted that CIDA was listed
as a potential source even though they already stated that this project would
not be renewed and the consultant mentioned that CIDA might review its position
not only because there were new people in the organization, but also because
there was a renewed interest in the region, especially in security and capacity
building.
It was also expressed that funding could be sought
on a case by case basis, depending on the project. This way, specific
organizations would be asked to fund events they are interested in, such as
regional security, the prevention of organized crime and cyber-crime could be
invoked to request funding.
It was noted that the fundraising approach should
consider strategic alliances with the private sector as a possibility, but it
should go hand in hand with the company’s corporate social responsibility,
especially in terms of environment, social justice, and human rights. The approach
could also consider international institutions, especially those interested in
women issues, small and medium enterprises, security, and the environment.
Finally, it was suggested that ParlAmericas could also work with local
parliaments.
8. Preparation for the 11th Plenary Assembly
a) Host country and Topics
The Plenary Assembly will be held in Santiago,
Chile, on September 25-27, 2014. Mr. Urrutia commented on some details
regarding the preparations and logistics with respect to the event. Mr. Hoback
encouraged the members to express their thoughts with the proposed themes.An
animated conversation followed, and the Members agreed and adopted that the
overarching theme of the 11th Plenary Assembly be Mainstreaming Sustainability,
and that the sub-topics be 1) Post-2015 Legislative Agenda in the Americas, 2)
Access to Information and the Digital Economy, 3) Meeting of the Group of Women
Parliamentarians: Women’s Healthcare.
It was further resolved that the Chairs of the
Working Groups be as follows:
1) Post-2015 Legislative Agenda in the Americas:
Guadalupe Valdez (Dominican Republic)
2) Access to Information and the Digital Economy:
Humberto Costa (Brazil)
3) Meeting of the Group of Women Parliamentarians:
Marcela Guerra (Mexico)
b) Review of Board Seats for Election
The seats that will be up for election at the next
Plenary Assembly were reviewed. Mr. Hoback reminded the board members that in
the last Plenary Assembly it was agreed to add an additional seat for each the
Caribbean and South America. It was reiterated that it was advisable that the
Board make a decision regarding which legislatures are able to run for a seat
on the Board; especially for those Parliaments who did not pay their dues for
several years. It was noted that the Parliaments who make the effort to pay
their dues should be compensated with the possibility of earning a seat on the
board. It was suggested to request additional information regarding the
participation of each member (payment of dues, hosting of events, attendance,
etc.) to enable a possible decision on the issue at the next board meeting.
9. Gathering of the Group of Women
Parliamentarians 2014
Ms. Simons updated the board on the conversations
she had been having regarding the main theme for the Gathering of the Group of
Women Parliamentarians. She said that the overarching theme would be “Moving
from Formal to Substantive Equality”. Session 1 would be “Breaching the Gap
between Written Law and Practice”; Session 2 would be “Education and Training
for Equality”; and Session 3 would be “Budgeting to Achieve Gender Equality”.
There was some discussion about which week would be the best to hold the event,
and Ms. Guerra offered to consult with the Senate of Mexico and send the
proposed dates to the President of ParlAmericas and to the President of the
Group of Women Parliamentarians.
It was agreed that the 2014 Gathering of the Group
of Women Parliamentarians will be held in Mexico City, in June.
10. Funding Beyond December 2014 – Part II
The Chair invited Mr. López-Hoyos, the consultant,
to continue the discussion on fund raising with the Board members. Amongst
suggestions, one included allowing hardware and software companies to come to
the Plenary Assembly venue and set up booths where they could show their
products. It was further stressed that ParlAmericas would not be endorsing any
particular vendor, but would give them access to all the parliamentarians in
attendance. Other ideas were debated such as electoral observation and it was
suggested to establish a “dos” and “don’ts” document.
Mr. Hoback warned that the current model would not
sustain itself, and therefore they should be willing to take on other projects.
He said that ParlAmericas could be revolutionary in the delivery of services.
Mr. López-Hoyos let the Board Members know that all discussions and input would
be taken into account in the preparation of the funding proposals. He also said
that he would keep them informed of which institutions were approached, so that
each member could reach out to his/her contacts. Finally, he thanked everyone
and declared he felt positive about obtaining funds for ParlAmericas.
11. Future Meetings and Close of Meeting
The 34th Board of Directors meeting will take
place in Mexico City, Mexico, immediately prior to the Gathering of the Group
of Women Parliamentarians.
Mr. Hoback acknowledged that this had been Ms.
Ruiz’s last board meeting and thanked her for all her work on the Board of
Directors of ParlAmericas. He also expressed his appreciation to Ms. Valdez and
her team for having hosted such a great meeting. Mr. Hoback presented both Ms.
Ruiz and Ms. Valdez with tokens of appreciation.
The Chair thanked everyone for their
participation, recognized the good job of the interpreters, and wished everyone
safe travels home.
There being no further discussion, Mr. Hoback
adjourned the meeting.
Respectfully
submitted,
Mr. Randy Hoback, M.P.
Chair,
Canadian Section of ParlAmericas