A delegation
of the Canadian Branch of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association visited
Australia from February 5 to 15, 2015. Mr. Joe Preston, M.P., Chair of the
Canadian Branch of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association, led the
delegation composed of Chris Charlton, M.P. and Rodger Cuzner, M.P. The
delegation was assisted by Ms. Elizabeth Kingston, Executive Secretary of the
Federal Branch.
During
their visit to Canberra, Australian Capital Territory (ACT), Sydney, New South
Wales; and Hobart, Tasmania the delegation met with their CPA counterparts,
legislators, government officials and individuals in the private sector. In
all instances they were received by the Presiding Officer or Officers of each
legislature.The CPA
constitution encourages visits between member countries with the objective of
giving parliamentarians the opportunity to discuss matters of common interest
in bilateral relations and issues within the international Commonwealth
organization. In addition, the visit objective was to further the Caribbean Initiative, a
project launched by the CPA Federal Branch and endorsed by all provinces and
territories across Canada. The project aims to provide a framework that allows
the legislatures of the Canadian Region of the Commonwealth Parliamentary
Association to establish working relationships with legislatures in the
Commonwealth Caribbean, along the lines of those undertaken between the
Australian and the Pacific Regions of CPA. The purpose of the project is to
increase cooperation between parliaments, including the sharing of ideas and
best practices. The delegation met with legislatures in Australia to learn more
of the projects undertaken and to witness first-hand the success of the
programme in the collaboration of Australian States and Territories with
Pacific island countries of the Commonwealth.
1)General
Overview:
The
Government of Australia is a constitutional monarchy with Queen Elizabeth II as
Head of State. The Commonwealth legislature is bicameral and consists of a
76-member Senate and a 150-member House of Representatives. Twelve senators represent each of the
six states and two from the mainland territories, all elected for a period of
six years. A system of rotation ensures that half the Senate retires every
three years. The four senators who represent the Australian Capital Territory
and the Northern Territory are elected concurrently with members of the House
of Representatives and the duration of their terms of office coincide with
those for that House (a maximum of three years). Each member represents a
single electoral division with roughly the same number of voters. Each of the six states and two
territories has their own legislature.
Federal
elections are held at least every three years. The last election was held on
September 7, 2013 and the writs for the half-Senate election cannot be issued
prior to July 1, 2016. The next House-only election will be called following
the dissolution or expiry of the current parliament and must be held on August
6 2016 at the earliest or January 14, 2017 at the latest.
Voting
is compulsory in Australia. The Senate and the House of Representatives have
different electoral systems. While both systems are preferential, the House of
Representatives ranks all candidates on the ballot paper in order of
preference. A successful candidate would be supported by 50% plus 1 votes. In
the event that no candidate receives more than 50% of first preference voters,
the next preference of voters for the other candidates are distributed until
one candidate emerges with the majority of votes. The Senate is elected by a
system of proportional representation.
At the
time of the visit, the delegation experienced the results of a spill motion or
leadership caucus vote, targeting the Prime Minister Tony Abbott. The Prime
Minister survived the challenge to his leadership brought about by a slide in
support for the Conservatives and resurgence for the Labor party following a
landslide defeat only 10 months prior.
2)Visit to
the Australian War Memorial:
The delegation
had the opportunity to have an extended visit to the Australian War Memorial
while in Canberra. The Australian War Memorial combines a shrine, a world-class
museum, and an extensive archive. The Memorial's purpose is to commemorate the
sacrifice of those Australians who have died in war. Its mission is to assist
Australians to remember, interpret and understand the Australian experience of
war and its enduring impact on Australian society. It was opened in 1941, and
is widely regarded as one of the most significant memorials of its type in the
world. Delegates noted the clear line of sight from the War Memorial to
Parliament House.
The
Australian War Memorial consists of three parts: the Commemorative Area
including the Hall of Memory with the Tomb of the Unknown Australian Soldier,
the Memorial's galleries and an extensive Research Centre. The Memorial also
has an outdoor Sculpture Garden. Each year on Anzac Day (25 April) and
Remembrance Day (11 November), the two major days of commemoration in Australia,
the Memorial holds National Ceremonies on the Parade Ground. These are attended
by thousands of official guests and visitors and are followed by the wreath
laying at the Tomb of the Unknown Australian Soldier.
Anzac Day is
one of Australia’s most important national occasions. It marks the anniversary
of the first major military action fought by Australian and New Zealand forces
during the First World War. Australian and New Zealand soldiers formed part of
the expedition that set out to capture the Gallipoli peninsula in order to open
the Dardanelles to the allied navies. The ultimate objective was to capture
Constantinople (now Istanbul), the capital of the Ottoman Empire, and an ally
of Germany. Both sides suffered heavy casualties with more than 8,000
Australian soldiers killed. The Gallipoli campaign had a profound impact on
Australians at home, and April 25 soon became the day on which Australians
remembered the sacrifice of those who died in the war.
3)Meeting
with the Presiding Officers – Senator the Honourable Stephen Parry, President
of the Senate and Hon Bronwyn Bishop, Speaker of the House of Representatives:
The
Honourable Stephen Parry is the Senate representative for Tasmania and has been
President of the Senate since July 2014. The Honourable Bronwyn Bishop, the
member for Mackellar, New South Wales and the 29th Speaker of the
House of Representatives, held the office as of November 2013.
The
meeting offered the opportunity for the delegation to review the various
reasons why the Federal Parliament of Australia had decided to withdraw from
the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association and to discuss how Australia might
reconsider this position and return to the membership. Although the Australian
states continue to be active members of the Commonwealth Parliamentary
Association, the Federal Branch decided to cease its membership effective
January 2012. Reasons include concerns regarding the financial and
administrative stewardship of the Association. Australia stated that they would
watch carefully the succession of the Secretary General and determine at a
later date the possibility of resuming its membership. As a competition process
had been launched, there is hope that Australia might return once the new
regime is in place. Both the Canadian delegation and their Australian
counterparts suggested that Canada would play an instrumental role in assisting
Australia in determining whether or not it would wish to rejoin.
The
principal reasons for leaving stemmed from the deficiencies in the accountability
and consultation mechanisms of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association
headquarters in London, United Kingdom especially at the time when Dr. Shija,
the now deceased Secretary General had been in charge. There was hope expressed
with the newly elected Executive Committee (EXCO) Chairperson, Dr. Shirin Sharmin Chaudhury.
She is the first woman Speaker of the Bangladeshi Parliament, and has had much
experience working with Commonwealth countries and governments. Moreover, the
international job search for a new Secretary General could do much to
revitalize the effectiveness of the Association.
The
delegation also had the opportunity to discuss the Caribbean Twinning
Initiative, modelled after the most successful program presently underway in
Australia with Pacific island countries of the Commonwealth. Both Speakers were
impressed by this initiative in the Americas context and offered their support
whenever necessary.
4)Meeting
with the Speaker and Clerk of the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) Legislative
Assembly:
The
delegation met with the Speaker, Mrs. Vicki Dunne, MLA and the Clerk, Tom
Duncan of the ACT Legislative Assembly while in Canberra.
The ACT
legislature is a unicameral assembly, unlike most parliaments in Australia. It
has 17 members from three constituencies, each elected for four-year terms by
the Hare-Clark System variation of the single transferable vote of proportional
representation. The Assembly was originally elected by a modified d’Hondt
system, but a 1992 referendum supported the Hare-Clark method, introduced in
1993.
The ACT
was initially managed by a federal minister responsible for the territories.
Self-government began in 1988 when the federal government passed the Australian
Capital Territory (Self-Government) Act. Since the ACT has no local
council, the legislature is responsible for both territory and local government
functions.
As part
of the CPA`s twinning initiative, the ACT Legislative Assembly has a
partnership arrangement with the Parliament of Kiribati. One of the Committee
rooms in the legislative building is devoted to highlighting this twinning
relationship. Projects have included an orientation program for new
parliamentarians, held in Kiribati in November 2011. There is also a recommendation that the ACT Branch agree
to visits between the two branches at least once every Assembly by members and
officers of the respective parliaments.
In
addition to discussions concerning the successful twinning program, the
delegation held a meeting with the Speaker to discuss the withdrawal of the
Australia federal branch of the CPA stating that while Canada shares the
concerns expressed by the Australia federal branch, the Canadian membership is
of the view that such problems can only be corrected by working within the Association
rather than withdrawing completely. The Speaker, Vicki Dunne, who is a member
of the CPA Executive Committee (EXCO), is in agreement with the Canadian
perspective.
5)Visit
to Sydney, New South Wales:
The
visit to Sydney had two objectives for the delegation: an insight into Canadian
investment in Australia and an understanding of the twinning program undertaken
by the New South Wales Parliament with Bougainville and the Solomon Islands.
New South Wales is the largest state in Australia with a population of 7.5
million, of which about two-thirds reside in Sydney.
Australia
is the largest destination for Canadian investment in the Asia Pacific region
and is seen by many Canadian companies as a springboard into neighbouring
markets. In this regard, Australia is a major regional contributor. Its economy
is relatively strong from a global perspective, and it maintains a favourable
business climate and strong and growing relationships with the emerging
economies of the Asia Pacific.
Much
of Canada`s trade with Australia is placed between companies in traditional
sectors such as mining and transportation, with a significant growing interest
in Canadian oil and gas suppliers and service providers. In addition, Canadian
industry opportunities in agri-food, ICT, life sciences, clean technology,
renewable energy, green building and defence procurement offer opportunities
that are well suited to the Australian marketplace. In addition, Australian
think tanks, academics, and corporations are interested in sharing knowledge
and expertise in the area of corporate social responsibility, especially as it
relates to the real challenges that prevail in the nearby Pacific Island
countries.
The
delegation received an extensive briefing from several stakeholders in the Canada-Australia
marketplace, ranging from Blackberry, RBC Capital Markets, the MBO group,
specializing in assisting with acquisitions of private companies, Minter
Ellison law firm, Murdock Cheng legal practice, the Black Diamond Group,
specializing in world-renowned
experience in domestic and international modular building projects and OpenText, the global
leader in enterprise information management. All companies recognized the
tremendous potential of being positioned in Australia, not only as a stable marketplace,
but also its solid links to the ASEAN Marketplace. Australia is known for its
active agenda of trade liberalization with other Asian countries, having signed
free trade agreements with New Zealand, Singapore, the United States, Thailand,
Chile, Malaysia, South Korea, Japan and most recently China. Canada can only
benefit from this spirited trade approach, especially now within the context of
the Trans-Pacific Partnership negotiations. Such an agreement, they argue would
provide for an enhanced value chain participation by Canadian suppliers, secure
investment provisions in line with Canada`s investment abroad and domestic
objectives, while providing for substantially increased market access for a
wide range of goods and services.
6)Visit
to the New South Wales Parliament:
New
South Wales (NSW) has Australia`s oldest Westminster-style Legislature dating
back to 1856. The Parliament consists of two houses: the Legislative Council
and the Legislative Assembly. The legislative Council houses 42 members, all
elected by proportional, optional preferential voting. Members are elected from
State-wide elections, with the entire State acting as a single electoral
district. The term is fixed at eight years, with half of the Council being
elected every four years. The Legislative Assembly houses 93 members (MLA`s),
all elected by optional preferential voting, with voters ranking one or more
candidates in order of preference. Each MLA represents one electoral district
with a maximum term of four years.
The
delegation had the opportunity to meet with the President of the Legislative
Council, the Honourable Don Harwin. The discussion centred around the twinning
relationship that the Parliament has established with the Parliaments of the
Autonomous Region of Bougainville (the Bougainville House of Representatives)
and the Solomon Islands (the National Parliament of the Solomon Islands) as
established in June 2007. During the time of the visit, Ignatius Hamal,
Executive Officer to the Clerk, had undertook a four-week secondment to the NSW
Parliament to develop material on the application of parliamentary privilege in
the Bougainville context. With respect to the Solomon Islands, Patteson Lusi,
Director of Civic Education, was on secondment from the National Parliament of
Solomon Islands, employed in a part time capacity by the NSW Parliament to
undertake research and writing tasks related to the Twinning project.
Delegation members were most impressed by the scope of the projects undertaken
by these Parliaments, recognizing the tremendous benefit that similar projects
within the Caribbean twinning initiative would provide within our own
hemispheric context.
7)Visit to
the Parliament of Tasmania:
Tasmania
is Australia`s smallest state with most of the 514,800 population residing in
the capital Hobart. It has a bicameral Parliament composed of the Legislative
Council and the House of Assembly. The Legislative Council is unique in that it
always has had a majority of independent members, and as a result has never
been controlled by any government or political party. It is comprised of 15
members all elected by optional preferential voting with the members elected
from single-member electorates. The term is fixed for 6 years, with periodical
elections held for either two or three electorates every year.
The
House of Assembly is comprised of 25 members, elected by proportional
representation, single transferable voting system whereby each voter must
indicate a minimum of five candidate preferences. Each of the five electoral districts
is represented by 5 MLA`s, serving for a maximum term of 4 years.
Meetings
were held with the President of the Legislative Council, James Scott Wilkinson
and the Speaker of the House of Assembly, Elise Archer as well as Michelle
O`Byrne, Member of the House of Assembly and a very active member of the CPA
and CWP (Commonwealth Women Parliamentarians). They discussed the twinning
partnership arrangement undertaken between the Parliament of Tasmania and the
Parliament of Samoa. One
key outcome of the program has been the establishment of the community outreach
office, which aims to foster greater engagement between the Parliament and the
community, encouraging participation while increasing awareness on matters
related to parliamentary work. A project has also been undertaken to increase
the number of women in the Samoa Parliament.
8)Visit
to Incat and Liferaft Systems (LSA):
Delegation
members visited the shipyard building site for Incat. The company based in
Hobart, Tasmania provides
lightweight aluminum ship solutions for ferry operators, special service
providers and militaries, including vehicle-passenger ferries, military support
vessels and crew ships. The design of the Incat craft provides for greater
speed and stability. Members toured a ferry in its final building stages that
was destined for the Japanese market.
The
delegation then toured Liferaft Systems (LSA), a company providing rapid and
safe evacuation of passengers and crew into large capacity life rafts. The
unique design was conceived in 1992 and these life rafts are now installed on
all types and sizes of passenger & personnel carrying vessels, including
conventional ferries, high-speed craft, military vessels and large private
yachts worldwide. LSA has sold its life raft systems to B.C Ferries and has a
North American presence in Vancouver, British Columbia.
9)Visit to
the Institute for Marine and Antarctic Studies (IMAS):
IMAS is
a Centre of excellence for marine and Antarctic research. It was established in
2010 as a teaching and research institute of the University of Tasmania and
builds upon more than 20 years of university core partnership in cooperative
Antarctic research, and looks to provide a similar role in temperate marine and
Southern Ocean research. Its research goes beyond traditional scientific and
social scientific conventions, and the Centre works to develop environmental
understanding and sustainable development for the benefit of Australia and the
world.
The
three core research
programs are fisheries and aquaculture, ecology and biodiversity and oceans and
cryosphere linked to climate change, ocean-earth systems and oceans and
Antarctic governance.
In closing, the
delegation would like to express its appreciation to the Canadian High
Commission in Canberra as well as the consulate in Sydney and particularly the
Consul General Mario Ste-Marie and Louise Hannan Consul & Senior Trade
Commissioner, for their valuable advice and assistance in arranging the
meetings associated with the visit. The delegation would also like to thank
the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade and Development (DFATD) and the
Library of Parliament for the provision of briefing material and for briefings
prior to departure.
Respectfully
submitted,
Mr.
Rodger Cuzner, M.P.
Canadian Branch of
the
Commonwealth Parliamentary Association (CPA)