From 4–6 May 2014, Mr. Gord Brown, M.P., Co-Chair
and three Vice-Chairs – Senator Michael L. MacDonald, Mr. Brian Masse,
M.P. and Mr. LaVar Payne, M.P. – represented the Canadian Section of the
Canada-United States Inter-Parliamentary Group (IPG) at the spring meeting of
the Canadian/American (Can/Am) Border Trade Alliance (BTA) in Ottawa, Ontario.
Mr. Brown and Senator MacDonald provided remarks at the meeting. The delegation
was accompanied by Mr. Pascal Tremblay, Advisor to the Canadian Section.
THE EVENT
The Can/Am BTA holds two meetings each year: in
the spring in Ottawa and in the fall in Washington, D.C. The BTA is a coalition
of businesses, public-sector organizations and individuals with an interest in
bilateral trade and tourism. Its mission is to maximize commercial activity and
ensure continued growth in cross-border trade, as well as efficient and
productive border-crossing capabilities.
Attendees at the event included private-sector
representatives involved in a number of transportation and trade-related
activities, as well as representatives of a variety of Canadian governmental
departments and the United States’ Embassy in Ottawa.
DELEGATION OBJECTIVES FOR THE EVENT
Members of the Canadian Section sometimes attend
both the spring and fall meetings of the BTA. Given the BTA’s focus, attendance
at the meetings provides members with an important opportunity to gain insights
about the problems being experienced by businesses and individuals in respect
of trade and tourism, as well as about efforts and actions by governments in
both countries to address these problems.
Attendance at the BTA meetings also provides
members of the Canadian Section with an opportunity to inform meeting attendees
about the range of actions taken by them in respect of shared bilateral goals,
especially through the invitation that is typically given to the Canadian
Senate and House of Commons Co-Chairs and/or Vice-Chairs to provide remarks
about the Canadian Section’s past and future activities and priorities. As
noted earlier, Mr. Brown and Senator MacDonald provided remarks at this
meeting.
ACTIVITIES DURING THE EVENT
Members of the Canadian Section were able to speak
with meeting attendees about the problems being encountered at Canada’s shared
border with the United States, and to share information about the efforts being
taken by the Canada-United States Inter-Parliamentary Group to ensure the
existence of an efficient, cost-effective and secure shared border. The
Canadian Section’s House of Commons Co-Chair, Mr. Gord Brown, M.P., spoke about
the Canadian Section’s activities since the BTA’s fall meeting in 2013, while
Senator MacDonald discussed the Canadian Section’s upcoming activities.
Sessions with the following titles were held:
·Introductory remarks by the U.S. Ambassador to
Canada
·Beyond the Border Action Plan on perimeter
security and economic competitiveness
·View from the bridges
·Alberta’s oil sands
·Single Window Initiative
·Canada-United States Inter-Parliamentary Group
·View from the Canadian Council of Chief
Executives
·Shale oil and gas: overview
·View from the rail
·Transportation
·Beyond the Border implementation
·Canada Border Services Agency: Beyond the Border
·View from Can/Am BTA
·Canada Border Services Agency: information
technology and “exponential technology”
·Oil sands and energy: overview and their
importance to U.S. and Canada.
This report summarizes selected presentations made
at the meeting, including the remarks by Mr. Brown and Senator MacDonald.
INTRODUCTORY REMARKS BY THE U.S. AMBASSADOR TO
CANADA
Ambassador Bruce Heyman, U.S. Embassy
·The goals and objectives in the Beyond the
Border Action Plan must be realized; momentum must be maintained, and a high
level of commitment to achieve efficient borders is needed.
·Since its inception, NEXUS has enrolled 1
million members, but wait times at the border shared by the United States and
Canada can still be significant.
·U.S.–Canada trade leads to significant economic
benefits, including jobs in both countries.
·The United States has concerns about the
intellectual property rights bill being considered by the Canadian Parliament,
as it would not stop foreign counterfeit goods from transiting through Canada
to the United States; a failure to address the issue of in-transit counterfeit
goods could result in more intrusive inspections at the shared land border.
BEYOND THE BORDER ACTION PLAN ON PERIMETER
SECURITY AND ECONOMIC COMPETITIVENESS
Honourable Steven Blaney, P.C., M.P., Canadian
Minister for Public Safety
·The flow of goods and services, and the movement
of people, across the Canada–U.S. border support jobs and the economy in each
country; for most U.S. states, Canada is the main trading partner.
·It is critical to move forward with efforts to
make the Canada-U.S. border more reliable in order both to ensure mutual
security and to benefit from bilateral trade.
·Trusted traveller and trusted trader initiatives
are key initiatives to facilitate crossings at the border between the United
States and Canada.
·A number of initiatives, including preclearance
pilot projects, are critical to enhance and facilitate Canada-U.S. trade.
·In 2013, Canada and the United States released
the first-ever joint Canada-U.S. Border Infrastructure Investment Plan; the
plan aims to facilitate crossing of the border while enhancing security.
·Global competitiveness is critical, and requires
that the border shared by Canada and the United States
become more efficient.
ALBERTA’S OIL SANDS
David Kettles, Government of Alberta
·Alberta’s oil sands generate jobs and wealth for
Alberta, Canada and the United States; suppliers on both sides of the shared
border benefit from the development of the oil sands.
·Alberta is investing in carbon capture and
storage projects in order to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.
·Companies that are required to meet the
provincial reduction target for GHG emissions pay, to the Climate Change and
Emissions Management Fund (CCEMF), $15 for every tonne of GHG emissions that
exceed the reduction limit.
·The CCEMF has collected $398 million since 2007;
this money is being invested in GHG emissions reduction projects.
SINGLE WINDOW INITIATIVE
Ryan Eickmeier, GS 1 Canada
·The GS 1 barcode system identifies, captures and
shares information on products across the entire supply chain, and helps
respond to businesses’ logistical needs and challenges.
·The GS 1 barcode system’s standards facilitate
logistics, bring about increased supply-chain efficiency, and help to move
products across the Canada-U.S. border.
·The GS 1 barcode system allows access to
real-time information about the flow of products and transactions, enables
precise tracking of shipments, vehicles, containers and warehouses’
inventories, and results in border crossings that are seamless, secure and
efficient.
·The GS 1 barcode system is harmonized with the
Single Window Initiative.
·According to findings from a pilot project,
using GS 1 standards can reduce U.S. Consumer Product Safety examinations of
toy products by 75% or more.
CANADA-U.S. INTER-PARLIAMENTARY GROUP
Senator Michael L. MacDonald, Senate of Canada
·The first meeting attended by the IPG’s Canadian
Section since the BTA’s fall 2013 meeting in Washington, D.C. was a meeting of
the Council of State Governments’ Eastern Regional Conference, which had the
theme of “Succeeding in a Time of Austerity”; discussions occurred about a
number of resolutions that affect Canada, including the United States’
country-of-origin labelling requirements and the need to expedite customs
preclearance agreements.
·The next activity for the Canadian Section was
the winter meeting of the National Governors Association (NGA) in Washington,
D.C., which had the theme of “America Works: Education and Training for
Tomorrow’s Jobs”; at the NGA meeting, members of the Canadian Section spoke
with U.S. governors about issues that are important to both Canada and the
United States, including the scope of the Canada-U.S. trade relationship, the
Keystone XL pipeline proposal and other energy issues, financing of the new
Detroit-Windsor international crossing, abuse of prescription medicines, the
benefits of early learning for children, and a range of water issues.
·Following the NGA meeting, members of the
Canadian Section took advantage of their time in Washington to meet with
representatives of the Canadian American Business Council (CABC), and to
discuss such issues as the Keystone XL pipeline application, the U.S. customs
plaza at the Detroit-Windsor crossing and other shared border topics, the
safety of the transportation of goods by rail, truck pre-clearance at the Peace
Bridge, regulatory cooperation between Canada and the United States, and the
importance of North American supply chains.
·Following the meeting with the CABC, the
Canadian Section’s Senate and House of Commons co-chairs led a delegation of
their Senate and House colleagues to meetings with more than 50 U.S. Senators
and members of the House of Representatives or their staff; key topics
discussed during the Congressional meetings included the Keystone XL pipeline
proposal, ballast water regulations, the U.S. customs plaza at the new
Detroit-Windsor international crossing, U.S. country-of-origin labelling
requirements, and Buy American and other measures that harm trade and limit
prosperity.
·In April, members of the Canadian Section of the
IPG met with Nevada Governor Brian Sandoval, who was leading his state’s
first-ever official Canadian trade mission; among the topics discussed were the
significant levels of tourism and trade between Canada and Nevada.
Gord Brown, M.P., Canadian House of Commons
·The IPG’s annual meeting will be hosted by
Canada in Ottawa, beginning on 6 June 2014; up to 20 U.S. Senators and members
of the House of Representatives are expected to attend the annual meeting,
whose agenda items are likely to include border issues, as well as other topics
linked to growth and prosperity in Canada and the United States.
·Over the summer of 2014, members of the IPG’s
Canadian Section are planning to attend various meetings of governors and of
state legislators, as well as of private-sector/public-sector organizations
that involve governors or state legislators.
·The participation of the Canadian Section at
meetings of governors and state legislators is an important means by which to
learn from the experiences of the U.S. state and federal governments, to find
ways of maximizing North American prosperity, and to identify areas where
bilateral cooperation would be fruitful.
VIEW FROM THE Canadian Council of Chief Executives
Eric Miller, Canadian Council of Chief Executives
·Canada and the United States have a special
relationship, but this relationship is facing challenges; challenges in the
Canada-U.S. relationship include the slow pace of progress on the U.S. plaza at
the Detroit River International Crossing, the completion of a pre-clearance
agreement, and U.S. country-of-origin labelling requirements in relation to
beef and pork.
·Although there are currently 84 pipelines
connecting Canada and the United States, the Keystone XL pipeline approval
process has become a significant irritant in the bilateral relationship; the
Keystone XL pipeline is key to U.S. and North American energy security.
·The Trans-Pacific Partnership negotiations
should be a priority for Canada.
·As American politics are primarily local, Canada
should not have closed several consulates in the United States.
·The relationships between U.S. states and
Canadian provinces/territories are very important.
SHALE OIL AND GAS: OVERVIEW
Rayola Dougher, American Petroleum Institute
·Shale oil and gas play an important economic
role in Canada, the United States and Mexico.
·The use of natural gas has increased
significantly, and North American shale gas and oil production has changed a
lot from 1970 to the present time.
·From 2000 to 2013, U.S. shale oil production
increased from 90,000 barrels daily to 1 million barrels a day.
·Economic growth depends on energy growth.
TRANSPORTATION
Honourable Lisa Raitt, P.C., M.P., Canadian
Minister of Transport
·Transport Canada is actively working to advance
the Beyond the Border Action Plan.
·Transport Canada aims to diminish “red tape” and
increase efficiencies, including through the removal of bottlenecks and the
implementation of online forms.
·Canada is investing in its gateways; the
establishment and consolidation of Canada’s gateways transportation network is
important, as the integration of railways, roads and ports results in improved
efficiency.
·Examples of federal investments in gateways
include the Asia-Pacific Gateway and Corridor Initiative, the Great Lakes-St.
Lawrence Seaway and the Detroit River International Crossing.
·Having the world’s longest border necessitates
having a great working relationship between Canada and the United States.
·Canada and the United States not only trade with
each other; they also make things together and sell them to the world.
·The leaders of the three North American Free
Trade Agreement countries have recently committed to develop a North
American transportation plan.
·Effective, integrated North American supply
chains are a global competitive advantage; the efficiency of Canada-U.S. supply
chains must continually improve to remain competitive.
·Facilitating North American trade is critical,
and that trade depends on an efficient transportation system.
BEYOND THE BORDER IMPLEMENTATION
Kevin O’Shea, Canadian Privy Council Office
·Canada and the United States have the world’s
largest bilateral trade relationship.
·Regulatory cooperation is at the core of North
American competitiveness; deeper cooperation is necessary in order to reduce
transaction costs.
·The Single Window Initiative, which will enable
traders to submit electronically all information required to comply with
customs and other governmental regulations, is critical to North American
competitiveness.
·Border infrastructure investments are important,
but it is also essential to innovate and streamline processes (e.g.,
preclearance, pre-inspection, etc.).
·Canada is concerned about the relatively low
level of attention paid to border infrastructure investments in the United States,
and about inspection-related border fees.
·The 2014 annual report in relation to the Beyond
the Border Action Plan will outline the progress made in a number of areas,
although implementation of that plan is behind schedule; for instance, while
business travel has been facilitated, some issues continue to exist, and
completing pre-clearance agreements for rail, land and marine will require more
time.
CANADA BORDER SERVICES AGENCY: BEYOND THE BORDER
Richard Wex, Canada Border Services Agency
·The CBSA has a broad and complex mandate; key
challenges exist in relation to trade, travel and transnational criminal
activity.
·At present, the CBSA employs 13,000 personnel at
1,200 locations, including 7,200 individuals who are in uniform and 4,000
individuals who are armed.
·Operations at the Canada-U.S. border are
transitioning from border control to border management, which is based on a
risk management-based approach; this approach is focused on the detection and
identification of patterns of non-compliance to enable more targeted and
effective border controls.
·CBSA programs will benefit from strengthening
data analytics.
·The success of border control efforts depends on
partnerships; the CBSA aims to improve partnerships with stakeholders,
including with private-sector stakeholders, in order to optimize border
management.
VIEW FROM CAN/AM BTA
Jim Phillips, Canadian/American Border Trade
Alliance
·A paradigm shift in border management is needed,
and North American competitiveness and an enhanced quality of life depend on
it.
·A “pre-clearance paradigm shift” would
facilitate border crossings and trade, with benefits for both Canada and the
United States.
CANADA BORDER SERVICES AGENCY: information
technology and “exponential technology”
Maurice Chenier, Canada Border Services Agency
Technology is central to the CBSA, and
technological improvements require a good plan and effective direction; the
CBSA needs to be more efficient now than it has been in the past regarding its
use of information technologies.
The facilitation and security of international
trade and travel require technical solutions.
Automation is key in order to make good use of
data, and interoperability with the United States must be achieved; in this
regard, the Single Window Initiative is a linchpin to an efficient border.
Oil Sands & Energy: Overview and their
Importance to U.S. and Canada
Bridget Pastoor, MLA, Legislative Assembly of
Alberta
Alberta, Canada and the United States have
recently experienced robust growth in trade, travel and tourism, and the North
American economy requires fluid border processes.
Increasing market access for energy resources is
Alberta’s first priority; the province’s oil sands currently produce 1.9
million barrels each day, and this production is expected to grow to 3.2
million barrels by 2024.
Canada and the United States benefit from
Alberta’s oil sands sector, as the value of the province’s oil exports to the
United States comprise 25% of the value of Canada’s total exports to the
country, and 900 U.S. businesses are suppliers to this sector.
At present, about 180,000 barrels per day of
Canadian oil are transported by rail in the United States; this figure is
expected to increase, as rail transport is a substitute for the Keystone XL
pipeline.
North America might be energy independent by 2024,
and might become a net exporter of energy products.
Respectfully submitted,
Hon. Janis G. Johnson
Senator, Co-Chair
Canada-United States
Inter-Parliamentary Group
Gord Brown, M.P.
Co-Chair Canada-United States
Inter-Parliamentary Group