At the invitation of the China Canada
Legislative Association (China), a Canadian parliamentary delegation, led by
the Co-chairs of the Canada China Legislative Association (Canada), the Hon. Joseph Day, Senator and Mr. Tom Wappel, Member of Parliament, visited the People’s
Republic of China from October 7 to 15, 2006. The delegation participated in
the Ninth Bilateral Consultations between the two respective associations.
Built upon the Eight Bilateral Consultations, which were held in Canada in June 2006, annual consultations are held on a rotational basis between the two
countries. Both sides agreed to strengthen the
mechanisms for exchanges, deepen friendship and further develop cooperation
between the two countries.
The visit began in Beijing where the
Bilateral Consultations and meetings with high ranking officials were held.
The delegation then proceeded to visit Guangzhou City (Guangdong Province.) This portion of the visit allowed the delegation to better understand the economic
development in China and the implications and potential for Canada. Guangdong Province is China’s major manufacturing centre for light
industry and enjoys a GDP of 13% GDP and accounts for 9% of China’s total GDP, 25% of its FDI, and 34% of its total exports.
The delegation concluded its visit in Macao, a former Portuguese colony that was retroceded to China in 1999. The Special Administrative Region of Macao offers business opportunities
in the areas of agri-food, transportation, entertainment, professional services
and security technology and provides yet a different perspective of China’s development.
Objectives
·To further strengthen the relationship between
Canadian parliamentarians and members of the National People’s Congress;
·To discuss the political relationship between Canada and China; and
·To promote bilateral trade and investment
opportunities.
Delegation:
Hon. Joseph Day, Senator Co-chair of
CCLA, Tom Wappel, M.P., Co-chair of CCLA, Hon. Jack Austin, P.C., Senator, Hon.
Pat Carney, P.C., Senator, Charles Hubbard, P.C., M.P. , John Maloney, M.P.,
Bob Mills, M.P., Gord Brown, M.P., Daryl Kramp, M.P., Luc Malo, M.P., Norm
Radford, Secretary to the delegation
Official Meetings:
Beijing: Mr. Wu Bangguo, Chairman of the National People’s Congress
Standing Committee; Mr Sheng Huaren, Vice-chair and Secretary General of the
Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress; Mr. Lu Congmin,
Vice-Chair of Foreign Affairs Committee, National People’s Congress and Chair
of the CCLA. Mr. He Yafei, Assistant Minister of Foreign Affairs; Guangzhou:
Mr. Zhong Qiquan, Vice Chairman of the Standing Committee of Guangdong People’s
Congress; Mr. Chen Mingde, Vice Mayor of Guangzhou; Macao (Special Administrative
Region): Mr. Edmund Ho, Chief Executive of Macao.
Other Meetings and Activities
Guangzhou: Mr. Rick Li, Development Director, Guangdong Nortel Research and
Development; Canadian business representatives; the delegation visited Huamei-Bond International College; Macao (SAR): Mr. Ao Man-Long, Secretary for
Transport and Public Works. Mr. Echo Chan Keng Hong, Deputy President, Macao Trade and Investment Promotion Institute; the delegation visited the International
School of Macao.
In addition, the delegation received
comprehensive briefings from Ambassador Robert Wright and program managers from
the Canadian Embassy; Consul General Tim Coughlin and his senior officials from
the Consulate (Guangdong Province); and Consul General Gerry Campbell (Hong Kong) and his senior officials.
Beijing
Mr. Lu Congmin extended a very warm
welcome to the Canadian delegation and opened the meeting by providing a
positive scenario of the evolving relationship between Canada and China over the past thirty six years of diplomatic relations. Within this context, he
praised the long history and accomplishments of the two parliamentary
associations.
Parliamentarians raised a number of
issues including Approved Destination Status (ADS) for Canada, the rule of law, human rights, the importation of Canadian beef, energy, the environment and
bilateral relations between the two countries.
The Chinese reassured the Canadians
that the issue of ADS for Canada was of importance to China. However, according to the Chinese side, the onus is on the Canadian Government to take the
necessary steps to ensure the success of the negotiations.
Regarding the rule of law, the Chinese
informed the Canadians that legal reform in China became a government priority
in the 1990s. At that time, China enacted legislation designed to modernize
and professionalize the nation's lawyers, judges and property and commercial
laws. Individual human rights, commercial rights and property rights are now
protected under the Chinese Constitution.
The environment, the delegation was
told, has become a major preoccupation of the Chinese. The National People’s
Congress has enacted laws for environmental protection, which now form a basic
national policy for China. China will optimize its industrial structure to reduce
environmental degradation by decreasing coal dependency and increasing the use
of clean air technology. With regard to energy, the Chinese noted that Chinese
oil companies are investing in the Alberta Oil Sands.
On the question of the import of Canadian
beef, the Chinese noted that negotiations are ongoing.
A substantive discussion followed on
the subject of Canada-China bilateral relations. Although the Chinese noted
that Canada was a long-time friend of China, they expressed concern over the
apparent increase in “contradictions” between the two countries. The Chinese
raised the numerous recent visits to Taiwan by Canadian parliamentarians, the
granting of honourary Canadian citizenship to the Dalai Lama and the perceived
tolerance of Canadian authorities towards Falun Gong demonstrators. The
Canadian parliamentarians reassured their Chinese counterparts that the
Canadian government’s policy was consistent with that of previous governments.
The Canadians stressed that the Canada-China Legislative Association is the
only association officially recognized by the Parliament of Canada to conduct
bilateral exchanges with the National People’s Congress and, as such, travel by
Canadian parliamentarians on non-official activities are personal in nature and
do not reflect Canadian policy.
Mr. Lu Congmin concluded the
consultations by suggesting that the two associations clarify their respective
functions and responsibilities, establish better mechanisms for substantive
dialogue, promote the exchanges of parliamentary committees, draw lessons from
each country’s legislation and encourage participation of small-scale
delegations of parliamentarians in exchanges and seminars. Mr. Lu offered the
suggestions in the spirit of improving the relationship between the two
countries. The Chairs of the two associations agreed to exchange letters to
explore ways of enhancing their current relationship.
The Canadian Co-chairs formally
extended an invitation to their Chinese counterparts to visit Canada in 2007 and suggested Eastern Canada as a possible venue for the visit.
Other Meetings
The Canadian delegation was privileged
to meet with Mr. Wu Bangguo, Chairman of the National People’s Congress
Standing Committee and third in the national hierarchy, behind President Hu.
Mr. Wu stated that Canada and China have natural affinities which make them
trade partners. China remains thankful to Canada for being amongst the first
countries to establish diplomatic relations with China. He stressed the
importance of parliamentary diplomacy and that bilateral relationships cannot
proceed without the involvement of parliamentarians. He expressed the view
that differences between countries are not unusual and he echoed the comments
of Mr. Lu that Taiwan and Tibet were very sensitive issues. China, he stated, was pleased that the Canadian Government reiterated the “one-China” policy. He
stated that China’s rapid economic growth offered great potential for Canada and noted that there was an increase of 20% in two way trade in the first eight
months of 2006. The meeting concluded on the importance of finding common
ground between the two countries.
In its meeting with Mr. Sheng Huaren,
Vice-chair and Secretary General of the Standing Committee of the National
People’s Congress, the delegation had yet another opportunity to discuss the
bilateral relationship between the two countries. Mr. Sheng stressed the
importance of the exchange mechanism at the parliamentary level, explaining
that the CCLA was the oldest parliamentary association in the National People’
Congress. Such exchanges, he stressed, allow for the increased sharing of
information and reduction of misunderstandings. He expressed the wish that
trade between the two countries exceed 30 billion dollars (US) by 2010. Mr.
Sheng took the opportunity to express China’s deepest appreciation towards Senator
Jack Austin for his contribution to the bilateral relations over many years.
The delegation completed its series of
discussions in Beijing by meeting with Mr. He Yafie, Assistant Minister of
Foreign Affairs. The delegation had a very direct and frank discussion with
the Assistant Minister about Canada-China bilateral relations. The Assistant
Minister reiterated in an assertive fashion some points raised at earlier
meetings regarding “differences” in the bilateral relation. The Canadians
assured the Assistant Minister that Canada’s current foreign policy towards China was consistent with previous Canadian Governments. Delegates reiterated that under
the Canadian political system, travel to Taiwan by Canadian parliamentarians
was not indicative of the government’s foreign policy towards China, as these visits are of a non-official nature.
Guangzhou
As in all of its previous meetings, the
Chinese hosts, signaling the importance that they attach to the relationship
with Canada, warmly welcomed the delegation. Mr. Zhong Qiquan, Vice Chairman
of the Standing Committee of Guangdong People’s Congress (Guangdong Province), officially welcomed the delegation. Mr. Zhong provided an overview of Guangdong province, noting that its economic development was a result of the Deng Xiaoping
reforms in 1978 when Beijing designated Guangdong as a pilot province for
economic reform. The result is that Guangdong is now China’s major manufacturing centre for light industry. It enjoys a GDP of 13% GDP and accounts for
9% of China’s total GDP, 25% of its Foreign Direct Investment and 34% of its
total exports. It has a permanent population of 110 million habitants.
Mr. Zhong noted that although wealthy, Guangdong is still developing. Guangdong’s average per capita income of $ 2882.00 (CAN)
lags far behind that of Canada ($36,000.00 CAN). Thirty percent of the
population have social security pensions.
Some of the challenges the Province
faces are energy shortages, environmental pollution and regional imbalances.
He explained that the 11th Five Year Plan calls for a GDP Growth of
9% and a doubling of the annual income. Guangdong is aiming to become energy
sufficient and the government wishes to remove the disparities between rural
and urban areas.
Mr. Zhong, noting that Guangdong
Province has a sister relationship with the Province of British Columbia,
encouraged Canadian companies to invest in Guangdong, stating that the Nortel
R&D Research Centre, which the Canadian delegation visited during their
program, is a good example of a Canadian firm investing in China.
The delegation made a courtesy call on
Vice Mayor Chen Ming De of Guangzhou. The latter echoed the comments of Vice
Chairman Zhong Qiquan and emphasized the importance of the relationship with Canada, citing that Guangdong had a sister relationship with British Columbia and Guangzhou with the
City of Vancouver. The Vice Mayor provided an overview of the strong economic
performance of Guangdong since the reform policies of 1978. Guangzhou, he
stated, had the third highest GDP of the ten largest cities in China, after Beijing and Shanghai. The City is installing a new subway line and will be hosting the
ASEAN Games in 2010.
Macao (Special
Administrative Region)
The delegation met with Mr. Edmund Ho
Hau-wah, Chief Executive Officer of Macao, at his personal residence. He
extended a very warm welcome to the Canadians, saying how grateful he was that
the delegation could meet with him. He expressed Macao’s deepest appreciation
towards Canada for the excellent bilateral relationship. The Chief Executive
Officer noted that Canada is an important supplier of rib beef to Macao (Macao is the fourth largest market for Canadian rib beef) and that the market could
expand even further. The discussion shifted to the economic potential offered
by Macao to Canadian companies in such areas as environmental protection, waste
management and environmental technologies. The Chief Executive Officer
concluded by stating that Macao welcomes Canadian goods and urged Canadian
companies to take advantage of investment opportunities offered by Macao.
The Canadian delegation thanked Mr. Ho
Hau-wah for continuing the importation of Canadian beef during the difficult
time resulting from the discovery of BSE in a Canadian cow, while all around
him, countries were closing their borders to Canadian beef.
Hong Kong
(Special Administrative Region)
On Monday, October 16th, Tom Wappel,
Joint Chairman, held a meeting with Mrs. Cherry Tse, J.P., Permanent Secretary
for Constitutional Affairs, Constitutional Affairs Bureau, Government
Secretariat, Government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. The
purpose of the meeting was to receive a briefing and update on the selection
process for the Legislature and Chief Executive as well as recent initiatives
to modernize and democratize the process.
Mrs. Tse provided Mr. Wappel with
numerous reference documents in this regard, (now filed with the Executive
Secretary of the CCLA). She offered her continued cooperation should CCLA
membership need further information or updates.
Conclusion
This was the first official visit by a
multi Party Canadian Parliamentary delegation since the election of a new
Government in Canada in 2006. The visit provided important opportunities to
meet with high ranking officials, to discuss the evolving bilateral
relationship between the two countries and examine ways of enhancing the
friendship between parliamentarians while strengthening the mechanisms for
exchanges which will promote a positive working dialogue.
Respectfully
submitted,
Hon. Joseph Day, Senator Co-Chair Canada-China Legislative Association
Mr. Tom Wappel, M.P. Co-Chair
Canada-China Legislative Association